Sunday, December 2, 2012

Faith is Nihilism

Bryan Fischer says that not exploiting fossil fuels to the absolute maximum is like rejecting a birthday present from Jesus, and that if we don't maximally rape the environment then God's feelings will be vewy vewy hurt.

You know, once upon a time, religious activists in the US were actually pro-environment, because they felt it represented responsible stewardship over the Earth that God had given them. I suppose some would say that this represents a very dark turn in American religion over the past several decades, and they'd be right, but I also think it's symbolic of something greater: Faith is essentially nihilistic, and when faith inspires goodness, it is no more reliable than the "goodness" of an avowed nihilist doing an incidentally good deed because it gives her momentary pleasure.

Revealed truth is an invalid epistemology. It can lead to any possible conclusion. And that makes it just as good as no epistemology at all; it makes it pure nihilism. It gives the believer the right to adhere to any philosophy she chooses, without the need for even a pretense of meaningful justification. "God said so" is as valid as "I feel like it."

Ironic that us atheists are always being painted with the broad brush of nihilism. There are nihilistic atheists to be sure, but ultimately it is only an epistemology based in science and reason which can transcend nihilism. Faith is not an escape from nihilism, it is an unrestrained embrace of it.

Faith is nihilism.

2 comments:

  1. You should check out the book "I don't have enough faith to be an atheist." I think its right up your alley. I somewhat reluctantly became a christian about 2 years ago due to finding a surprising amount of evidence for the miracles and resurrection of Christ. I'll just say that even though most christians you will meet aren't exactly the sharpest tools in the shed the evidence for Christ is compelling.

    -Blaze

    ReplyDelete
  2. If you say so, but I'm hoping you're not part of the camp that believes the flood occurred around 5K years ago given evidence in the Grand Canyon. Not at all compelling.

    ReplyDelete